Do You Need an LLC for a Side Hustle? What to Do First

Short answer: no, you do not need an LLC to start a side hustle in the United States. As soon as you earn money on your own, you are a sole proprietor by default, and that is legal, free and the way most people begin. An LLC becomes worth considering when the risk or the income grows: clients who can sue you, physical products, equipment, or profit that keeps climbing. This guide shows how to decide, what each option really changes at tax time, and the order of steps that avoids paying for paperwork you do not need yet.

This is educational content, not financial advice. It is not legal or tax advice either: rules differ by state, and a CPA or attorney can check your situation.

What you already are before you file anything

If you sell services, products or content on your own and have not set up a company, the IRS treats you as a sole proprietor: someone who owns an unincorporated business by themselves. There is no separate registration with the IRS to “become” one. The IRS lists the forms a sole proprietor typically uses: Form 1040 with Schedule C for income and expenses, Schedule SE for self-employment tax, and Form 1040-ES for quarterly estimated tax.

That matters because many beginners lose weeks (and money) on the wrong question. The first question is not “LLC or not?” It is “do I have paying customers yet?” If you are still testing an idea, see our guide to the first $1,000 online first and come back here when money starts arriving.

The three things a business structure actually changes

The Small Business Administration puts it plainly: your business structure affects how much you pay in taxes, your ability to raise money, the paperwork you need to file, and your personal liability. For a side hustle, only three of those matter in practice.

1. Personal liability

This is the real reason people form LLCs. The SBA’s comparison table lists sole proprietorships as having unlimited personal liability, while an LLC means owners are not personally liable in most instances. Translated: if a client sues over a mistake, or a product you sold injures someone, a sole proprietor’s personal savings and car can be on the line. An LLC can put a legal wall between the business and your personal assets, as long as you keep the two separate (more on that below).

Liability is about what you do, not just how much you earn. A person who designs logos from the couch carries very little risk. A person who sells baby products, repairs electronics, gives financial-sounding advice, or drives for clients carries much more.

2. Taxes: usually the same at first

Here is the part that surprises people. For federal income tax, an LLC with only one member is, by default, treated as a disregarded entity, separate from its owner for liability but not for income tax. The IRS says this holds unless the LLC files Form 8832 and elects to be taxed as a corporation. So a one-person LLC still reports profit on Schedule C, exactly like a sole proprietor.

Self-employment tax is the same too. The IRS states the self-employment tax rate is 15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security plus 2.9% for Medicare. An LLC alone does not lower it. If you want the full picture of what you owe on your first earnings, read our side hustle tax guide and the $400 rule explained.

Taxes only change when you elect S-corporation status, which the IRS handles under a separate set of rules. That is a conversation for a CPA and usually only makes sense when profit is well into five figures, not when you are making $300 a month.

3. Paperwork, cost and credibility

Forming an LLC means a state filing, a state fee, and often an annual report or fee afterward. Fees vary widely from state to state, so check your own Secretary of State website rather than trusting a number in a blog post. A sole proprietorship has none of that. On the other hand, an LLC gives you a business name that is registered at the state level, a cleaner bank account setup and a more professional look with larger clients.

Sole proprietor vs LLC: the comparison table

Sole proprietor (default) Single-member LLC
Setup Nothing to file with the IRS State filing and fee, then often annual reports
Personal liability Unlimited, per the SBA Generally limited, if kept separate
Federal income tax Schedule C on your 1040 Same, by default (disregarded entity)
Self-employment tax 15.3% on net earnings Same by default
Business bank account Recommended, not required Effectively required to keep liability protection
Best for Testing an idea, low-risk work Real risk, real income, or bigger clients

The free and cheap steps that matter more than the LLC

Most of the protection and organization people hope to get from an LLC can start today, for little or nothing.

  1. Open a separate bank account. Even a basic one. It makes tax time easy and, if you later form an LLC, it is the habit courts look for. Our freelance rate guide shows how to turn those deposits into a real hourly number.
  2. Get an EIN if you want one. The IRS says you can get an EIN directly from the IRS online in minutes, for free, and warns that you never have to pay a fee for an EIN. A sole proprietor can use an EIN instead of a Social Security number on client forms, which keeps your SSN off W-9s. Beware of sites that charge for this.
  3. Check your name. The SBA explains that a DBA (trade name) might be required by your state, county or city, but registering a DBA does not give you legal protection by itself. If you trade under a name other than your own, look up the local rule.
  4. Track every expense. A spreadsheet is enough. Software, a share of internet, fees from platforms: they reduce your taxable profit. See how platform fees bite in our Upwork vs Fiverr fee breakdown.
  5. Set aside tax money. Move a fixed percentage of each payment into a separate savings bucket so a quarterly payment never becomes a crisis.
  6. Buy the right insurance before the right entity. If you provide services, general or professional liability insurance can cover a mistake that an LLC alone may not stop (an LLC does not protect you from your own negligence in many situations). Ask an insurance agent what fits your work.

When an LLC starts to make sense

Use these as signals, not rules. Two or more of them showing up together is a good reason to speak with a professional.

  • You handle other people’s property, money or health. Anything where a mistake could cost a client more than you earn.
  • You sell physical products. Defective-product claims are a classic reason sole proprietors form LLCs.
  • You sign contracts with larger companies. Some require a registered entity.
  • Your income is steady and growing. The cost of the filing becomes small compared with the money it protects.
  • You own valuable equipment or have a lease tied to the business.
  • You plan to bring in a partner. Two members change the default tax treatment, as the IRS notes.

When to skip the LLC for now

  • You are still validating the idea and earn little or nothing.
  • Your work is low-risk (writing, simple design, tutoring, resale of small items) and you carry no inventory.
  • Your state charges a high annual fee that would eat a large share of your profit.
  • You would be forming it only because a video said “real businesses have LLCs.”

That last point deserves a warning. In 2024 and 2025 the Federal Trade Commission took action against several companies that sold expensive “business-in-a-box” and “AI passive income” programs, often bundling LLC formation as part of the pitch. If someone tries to sell you a company formation as the first step of a get-rich plan, read what the FTC cases teach before paying.

The mistake that cancels an LLC’s protection

An LLC is not a magic shield. Mixing personal and business money is the most common way owners weaken it. Pay personal bills from the business account, run business income through a personal one, skip the paperwork the state requires, or fail to renew on time, and a court may be more willing to look past the company to you personally. The SBA says LLCs protect owners “in most instances,” not in every instance. Treat the entity like a real thing: own bank account, own contracts, signed in the company’s name, with the LLC suffix on invoices.

A simple decision path

  1. No paying customer yet? Stay a sole proprietor. Test the idea.
  2. First paying customers? Open a separate account, get a free EIN if you want one, track expenses and put tax money aside.
  3. Services with real risk, products, or bigger clients? Talk to an insurance agent and an attorney or CPA about an LLC in your state.
  4. Profit rising steadily? Ask a CPA whether an S-corp election could ever make sense for you. Do not decide that from a social media post.

Quick answers to common questions

Do I need an LLC to open a business bank account? Not always. Many banks let a sole proprietor open a business account with a trade name or an EIN, while an LLC account usually asks for the state filing documents. Ask the bank what it requires.

Can I form an LLC later without losing anything? Yes. Many people start as sole proprietors and form the company when income and risk justify it. Keep clean records now so the move is easy, and check how your state treats existing contracts and licenses.

Does an LLC mean I pay no taxes? No. By default the profit still flows to your personal return and self-employment tax still applies.

Is a sole proprietorship “illegal” for a side job? No. It is the default legal form for anyone earning on their own, and the IRS publishes the forms for it.

Who it’s for / Who should skip it

This guide is for you if you earn (or are about to earn) money from freelancing, selling online, content or services and you are unsure whether to spend money forming a company.

You can skip it if you already have a CPA or attorney guiding your entity choice, or you operate a business with employees, inventory at scale or regulated services (food, medical, financial advice). Those need tailored professional advice from day one.

The bottom line

An LLC is a liability tool, not a tax trick and not a status symbol. For most beginners, a separate bank account, an EIN, good records and the right insurance deliver most of the practical benefits at a fraction of the cost. Form the LLC when real risk or real income shows up, and then do it properly. Until then, stay lean and spend the money on getting your first customers. For the whole roadmap, start from our first $1,000 online guide.

This is educational content, not financial advice.

Sources

Scroll to Top