This is educational content, not financial advice.
Short answer: before you enter a card number on an unfamiliar Black Friday site, run seven checks: who runs the store, what others say about it, how you will pay, whether the price is believable, whether the seller states a shipping date, whether you saved the proof, and whether you know your 60-day dispute window. The Federal Trade Commission’s own advice boils down to the same few moves, and none of them needs more than two minutes. Below is the checklist, a table that shows which payment method gives you which protection, and what to do if you already paid.
Why fake stores spike in the week before Black Friday
The FTC’s holiday-season consumer alert is blunt about where the trouble starts. Scammers are “everywhere online” and especially on social media, where they sometimes impersonate real companies and run ads for brand-name products at unusually low prices. Click the link in the ad, the FTC says, and you could land on a website designed to take your money in exchange for a counterfeit item, something that looks completely different from the picture in the ad, or nothing at all (FTC Consumer Alert, November 2025).
That is why this week is risky: real stores really do cut prices, so a 60% discount stops looking suspicious. Fake stores borrow that cover. The goal is not to distrust every sale. It is to spend two minutes on any shop you have never bought from before.
The 7-check test (two minutes, no tools needed)
1. Start from the brand’s own website, not the ad
If an ad for a well-known brand shows a deal, type the brand’s address yourself or use your saved bookmark and look for the same deal there. If the deal exists, you will find it. If it exists only behind the ad link, treat that as a red flag.
2. Search the seller and the web address together
The FTC recommends searching for the seller’s name and the website URL the ad sends you to, plus words like “review,” “complaint,” or “scam,” to see what others say. A shop with no history at all, or whose only praise sits on its own pages, has not earned your card number yet.
3. Check how it wants to be paid
This is the clearest test. According to the FTC, if the seller says you can only pay with a gift card, wire transfer, payment app, or cryptocurrency, it is probably a scam. A legitimate store accepts ordinary card payments.
4. Ask whether the price is believable
The FTC’s wording is “unusually low prices” on brand-name products. Compare against two or three major retailers. If everyone else sells a console, a coat or a vacuum for roughly the same amount and one unknown site sells it for a fraction, the discount is the bait. For a broader pricing routine, see our Black Friday money guide and the walkthrough on using price trackers and chatbots together.
5. Look for a stated shipping date
The FTC notes that sellers have to ship your order by the time they or their ads say they will, or give you the chance to get your money back. A store that gives no delivery estimate at all, or one that keeps changing it after you pay, is giving you very little to hold it to. Our guide to Black Friday return rights covers what to check before you pay.
6. Keep the receipt and order confirmation
The FTC says that if something goes wrong, your receipt and order confirmation number can help you get your money back from the seller. Screenshot the product page with the price and promised delivery date, because scam pages disappear.
7. Know your dispute window before you need it
If you pay by credit card, federal law gives you a dispute process for billing errors, including charges for things you did not accept or that were not delivered as agreed. The catch is the clock: your written notice has to reach the card issuer within 60 days after the first bill containing the error was sent. The issuer must acknowledge it within 30 days and resolve it within 90 days, and while it investigates you can withhold the disputed amount (FTC: Using Credit Cards and Disputing Charges; CFPB: How do I dispute a charge on my credit card bill?).
Which payment method protects you? A quick comparison
| Payment method | What the official sources say | Our take |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card | FTC: if you are charged twice, billed for something you never got, or get a wrong or damaged item, you can dispute the charge with the card company. Federal billing-error process with 60-day notice, 30-day acknowledgment, 90-day resolution. | Best default for any shop you do not know. |
| Gift card, wire transfer, payment app, cryptocurrency | FTC: a seller who says you can only pay this way is probably a scam. | Walk away. |
| Debit card | Rules differ and are not the same as the credit-card process above. Check your bank’s terms before relying on it. | Use only at stores you already trust. |
If you are weighing card against installment plans, read our math on buy now, pay later versus a credit card. A dispute right only helps if you pay in a way that has one.
Gift cards: a second place holiday money goes missing
The FTC’s gift card guidance adds two practical rules for shoppers. First, stick to stores you know and trust, and avoid buying gift cards from online auction sites, because the cards may be fake or stolen. Second, inspect the card before you buy it: make sure the protective stickers are on and that the PIN on the back is not showing. Photograph the card and the store receipt, because those numbers are what the gift card company needs if you have to report fraud (FTC: Avoiding and Reporting Gift Card Scams).
The FTC’s warning on the other side is just as direct: only scammers will tell you to buy a gift card and read them the numbers. No real business or government agency will ever ask you to pay that way.
What to do if you already paid a fake store
- Call your card issuer now and tell them the order never arrived or the shop was fake. The CFPB says to call right away and also send a written billing error notice within 60 calendar days of the charge appearing on your statement. A phone call alone does not protect those legal rights.
- Write the dispute letter to the billing-inquiries address, not the payment address, with your name, address, account number and a description of the problem. Attach copies of receipts, not originals, and keep a copy of the letter.
- Keep paying the undisputed part of your bill. You can withhold the disputed amount while the issuer investigates, but the rest is still due.
- Report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The FTC asks you to tell them when you spot a scam.
- Watch your statements for new charges from the same shop, and consider a card replacement if the number may have been captured.
Who this checklist is for, and who can skip it
Who it’s for: anyone who plans to buy from a shop they have never used, anyone who clicked a social media ad for a brand-name product, and anyone shopping for holiday gifts on a tight budget, where a lost $150 hurts. It also helps if you are building a plan for the holiday spending in the first place; our six-week holiday budget pairs well with it.
Who should skip it: if you only buy directly from major retailers whose website you typed yourself, and you pay by credit card, you are already doing most of this. You can skim checks 6 and 7 and be done.
Our verdict
The cheapest protection against a Black Friday scam is boring: go to the store yourself, pay with a credit card, and save the proof. The expensive mistake is the opposite, a too-good price, an ad link and a payment method nobody can reverse. If a deal only works when you skip the checks, it is not a deal. We would rather miss one sale than start January disputing a charge for something that was never shipped.
